Marine Corps Tells Clubs They Must Admit Same Sex Spouses
The Marine Corps has advised its legal staff that spouses clubs operating on its installations must admit same-sex spouses if they wish to remain on the bases.
It’s a step that the other service branches have not yet announced as they deal with accommodating same-sex couples following repeal of the "don’t ask, don’t tell policy" that barred gays and lesbians from serving openly.
Underscoring the challenges, the Marines’ legal advisory refers to an ongoing controversy at the Army’s Fort Bragg in North Carolina where the officers’ spouses club has denied admission to a same-sex spouse.
The Marine Corps commandant’s Staff Judge Advocate, in an email to legal offices throughout the corps, said the Fort Bragg events had “caused quite a stir” and cautioned, “We do not want a story like this developing in our backyard.”
The memo noted that spouses clubs and various other private institutions are allowed to operate on bases only if they adhere to a non-discrimination policy encompassing race, religion, gender, age, disability and national origin.
“We would interpret a spouses club’s decision to exclude a same-sex spouse as sexual discrimination because the exclusion was based upon the spouse’s sex,” the memo said.
A Marine Corps spokesman, Capt. Eric Flanagan, said the Marines cannot directly control the actions of independent organizations such as spouses’ clubs, but added, “We expect that all who are interested in supporting Marine Corps Family Readiness would be welcome to participate and will be treated with dignity and respect.”
The Defense Department has not issued similar guidance covering all service branches, and for now is taking the stance that the Fort Bragg spouses club is conforming with the existing rules because the non-discrimination clause does not extend to sexual orientation.
OutServe-SLDN executive director Allyson Robinson said, "The Marine Corps guidance … is a breakthrough and a clear indication that Gen. Amos meant what he said when he promised Marines would lead the repeal of 'don't ask, don't tell." Secretary (Leon) Panetta should use his authority immediately to bring consistency across the services with regard to this issue and in doing so, a greater measure of equity to gay and lesbian service members and their families."
Stephen Peters of the American Military Partner Association, which advocates on behalf of partners and spouses of lesbian and gay service members, praised the Marine Corps – which had been the service branch most uneasy about repeal of "don’t ask, don’t tell."
“The Marine Corps putting its best foot forward is great news,” he said. “They’re being proactive about this.”
Peters said his organization would urge the Pentagon to implement a military-wide policy that would open all spouses clubs to same-sex spouses.
“You can’t have different standards with the different branches,” he said.
Peters’ organization has been one of several groups advocating on behalf of Ashley Broadway, the wife of Fort Bragg-based Lt. Col. Heather Mack, after Broadway was denied admittance into the officers’ spouses club.
The club has said it would reconsider its membership policies at an upcoming meeting.
Comments