Plenty of Evidence Ukrainian Prisoners R Traumatized and Sexually Abused

 

By Carlotta Gall and Oleksandr Chubko

Reporting from Kyiv, Ukraine

The New York Times

The Ukrainian marine infantryman endured nine months of physical and psychological torture as a Russian prisoner of war. Still, he was allotted only three months of rest and rehabilitation before being ordered back to his unit.

The infantryman, who asked to be identified only by his call sign, Smiley, returned to duty willingly. But it was only when he underwent intensive combat training in the weeks after that the depth and range of his injuries, both psychological and physical, began to surface.

“I started having flashbacks, and nightmares,” he said. “I would only sleep for two hours and wake up with my sleeping bag soaking wet.” He was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and referred for psychological care and is still receiving treatment.

Ukraine is just beginning to understand the lasting effects of the traumas its prisoners of war experienced in Russian captivity, but it has been failing to treat them properly and returning them to duty too early, say former prisoners, officials, and psychologists familiar with individual cases. 

Nearly 3,000 Ukrainian prisoners of war have been released from Russia in prisoner exchanges since the 2022 invasion began. More than 10,000 more remain in Russian custody, some of whom have endured two years of conditions that a United Nations expert described as horrific.

A person sits among a row of brightly colored seats near a window.

A Ukrainian infantryman whose call sign is Smiley endured nine months of physical and psychological torture as a Russian prisoner of war.Credit...Brendan Hoffman for The New York Times

The Ukrainian government’s rehabilitation program, which usually involves two months in a sanitarium and a month at home, is inadequate, critics say, and the traumas suffered by Ukrainian prisoners are growing with the length and severity of the abuse they are being subjected to as the war drags on. 

Russia’s torture of prisoners of war has been well documented by the United Nations, with former inmates speaking of relentless beatings, electric shocks, rape, sexual violence, and mock executions, so much so that one expert described it as a systematic, state-endorsed policy. Many detainees have also reported lingering symptoms like blackouts and fainting spells stemming from repeated blows to the head that were severe enough to cause concussions.

Ukraine’s prosecutor general, Andriy Kostin, said in September that “about 90 percent of Ukrainian prisoners of war have been subjected to torture, rape, threats of sexual violence or other forms of ill-treatment.” 

The Russian military did not answer a request for comment on the allegations of mistreatment of Ukrainian prisoners of war.

Most of the released prisoners have returned to active duty after about three months of rest and rehabilitation, as the Ukrainian military, short of troops on the front line, has given relatively few medical exemptions to former prisoners of war.

A law passed this month will allow former prisoners of war the choice of returning to service or being discharged from the military, recognizing that many have been subjected to severe mental and physical torture and need prolonged rehabilitation. Ukrainian officials acknowledged that there had been problems in providing sufficient care for former prisoners but said they had now developed special centers for them using best international practices.

Ukrainian prosecutors have identified 3,000 former military and civilian prisoners who can serve as witnesses for a case they are building for the Ukrainian courts to charge Russian individuals and officials with mistreatment of prisoners. The prosecutors encouraged two of the former prisoners to speak to The New York Times.

 

Several people sit around a wooden table with notebooks and other papers.

Family members of Ukrainian soldiers who continue to be held by Russia as prisoners of war meeting with Lyudmila Denisova left the former human rights ombudsman of Ukraine.Credit...Brendan Hoffman for The New York Times

One of them was Smiley, 22, who was captured at the beginning of the war when the Russian Navy seized Ukrainian positions on Snake Island in the Black Sea. He spoke a year after his release, saying he hoped that shedding light on the conditions of Russian prisons would help not only his own rehabilitation but also the thousands of prisoners of war still in captivity. 

“My sister persuaded me to give my first interview,” he said. “‘You need to tell,’ she said. Maybe if we speak, it will help the treatment of our guys.”

A second Ukrainian serviceman made available by the prosecutors gave a lengthy interview but declined to give his name or call sign because of the stigma surrounding the abuses he suffered.

The serviceman, 36, said he was taken prisoner along with several thousand soldiers and marines after a long siege at the Azovstal Iron and Steel Works in Mariupol in May 2022. He spent nine months in Russian captivity before being released in a prisoner exchange early last year.

He spent most of his time in three detention facilities in the Russian towns of Taganrog, Kamensk-Shakhtinsky, and Kursk. He returned critically underweight and suffering from an injured spine and, like many others, blackouts, dizziness, and ringing in the ears from frequent beatings on the head. 

“I am not fainting any longer,” the serviceman said, “but I have difficulties with my back and concussion, and a squeezing all the time of the area around my heart.” Despite his injuries, he was ordered to return to light duty as a guard after only two months’ rest in a sanitarium.

A person’s arm rests on a table, the rest of him in shadow.

A Ukrainian serviceman, 36, was taken prisoner after a long siege at the Azovstal Iron and Steel Works in Mariupol in May 2022.Credit...Brendan Hoffman for The New York Times

“I don’t know if I could run a kilometer,” he said.

 

Prisoners were subjected to brutal daily beatings on their legs, backs, and fingers, and mental and physical torture during interrogations, as well as hunger, cold, and a lack of medical care, he said. Three men died in custody during his imprisonment, including one who died in the communal cell they shared, he said.

Some of the Russian units guarding or interrogating the prisoners were worse than others, the two former prisoners said, but there were consistent beatings every morning at roll call and torture at most detention facilities. Interrogations would last 40 minutes and often consisted of electric shocks, blows to the head, and sexual abuse, real or threatened.

“They start with maximum violence,” the serviceman said. “They say, ‘You are lying, not telling us everything.’ They put a knife to your ear or offer to cut off one of your fingers.” 

Others would beat them on the back of the head so regularly that they lost consciousness, he said.

“If one gets tired, another takes over,” he recalled. “When you fall, they make you stand again. It can last 30 to 40 minutes. At the end, they say, ‘Why did you not tell us everything immediately?’”

A person holds a sign reading “Captivity is hell” in support of Ukraine’s Azov Regiment as a group of soldiers stands nearby. 

Soldiers from Ukraine’s Azov Regiment gathered in central Kyiv this month as their supporters held banners calling for the release of more than 900 of its soldiers held by Russia since the fall of Mariupol in 2022.Credit...Mauricio Lima for The New York Times

Smiley said much of the violence was of a sexual nature. One prison unit repeatedly struck the prisoners all over their bodies, including on the genitals, with batons that gave electric shocks, he said. On another occasion, he said, a cellmate was repeatedly kicked in the genitals during roll call, where the prisoners were lined up with their legs spread, facing a wall in a corridor. Smiley suffered permanent injury from an untreated broken pelvis from a truncheon blow and could not bend or lie down without assistance for two weeks. 

The International Committee of the Red Cross, which has very limited access to prisoners of war held in Russia, was not permitted to visit him during his nine months of imprisonment, he added.

The second serviceman said he was forced to strip and place his genitals on a stool as his interrogators hit them with a ruler and lay a knife on them, threatening to castrate him. 

Interrogators put him through a mock execution, firing a volley of gunfire beside him while he was blindfolded. They threatened him with rape, the serviceman said, making him choose what they should use — a mop handle or the leg of a chair. “Do you want to do it yourself or do you want us to help you?” they taunted him.

He said that he was never actually penetrated, but that others were raped. “After that you cannot walk normally,” he said. “You suffer for weeks. Other guys had the same treatment.”

“I think they had such an order to break us psychologically and physically so that we would not want anything else in life,” he said, adding that there were suicides in the Taganrog jail.

“You could hear the screams all day,” the serviceman said. “Impossible screams.” Sometimes during a lull, the prisoners could hear the voices of children playing outside, he said.

The ordeal for the former prisoners is by no means over once back home.

“The most difficult thing is having too many people around,” the serviceman said. “Everyone is peacefully walking in the park and you are still afraid that someone is listening, or that you might get shoved or say the wrong thing.” 

Maj. Valeria Subotina, a military press officer and a former journalist who was also taken prisoner at Azovstal and who spent a year in women’s prisons in Russia, recently opened a meeting space in Kyiv called YOUkraine, for former prisoners.

“There are many triggers, and people do not realize they still need care,” she said.

A person sits beside a window and looks into the distance.

Maj. Valeria Subotina, spent nearly a year as a prisoner of war in Russia after the siege of Azovstal in Mariupol, at the YOUkraine Hub in Kyiv.Credit...Brendan Hoffman for The New York Times

She returned to service three months after her release last April but found it hard to sit in an office. “I cannot bear someone approaching me from behind or standing behind me,” she said.

The government psychologists were of little use, she said. “They often don’t know how to help us,” she said, and civilians often ask careless questions.

As a result, many former prisoners find returning to the front line easier than rejoining civilian life, she said, and only fellow survivors really understand what they are going through.

“We don’t want to feel pity,” she said, “because we are proud that we survived and we overcame this.”