Trans Woman Killed but Azerbajjan Authorities Remain Quiet

 Written by:

Arzu Geybullayeva

Written byOC Media

This article was first published on OC Media. An edited version is republished here under a content partnership agreement. 

Azerbaijan's LGBTQI+ community was rocked by the news of yet another murder of a trans woman whose body was found on March 12 on the outskirts of the capital Baku. The news of the murder as well as the victim's photos were circulated among the #LGBTQI+ community. Minority Azerbaijan, an LGBTQI+ rights organisation in a statement asked anyone with additional information to come forward in an attempt to aid the investigation. Meanwhile, LGBTQI+ activists say authorities and local media keep silent over the case.

The victim

There is very little information about the victim, except her name – Aytan. According to LGBTQI+ activist Alex Shah who was the first to break the news on social media, Aytan was tortured and then killed. In a post on Meta, Shah said Aytan had no one to bury her body. Shah also called on the authorities, to investigate the case.

In a separate interview with OC Media, Shah also said, that after writing about the case on their social media, and tagging relevant state institutions, they were called in for questioning and informed that additional information is needed to open an investigation.

A spokesperson for the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Anar Gafarov, told OC Media that the ministry had no information about the case.

A spokesperson for the General Prosecutor’s Office, Aysel Hasanova, did not return OC Media's calls.

On March 21, Shah told OC Media, that two suspects, Aytan’s partner and landlord, were arrested.

The silent mode

Local queer rights activists accused the local media of silence in the case of the recent victim's murder. In an interview with OC Media, Leyla Hasanova, from the QueeRadar initiative, which monitors and documents LGBTIQI+ phobia in the Azerbaijani media, said, “The media is largely keeping silent, and we call it phobic silence.” By keeping silent, the media is actively contributing to the situation by not providing coverage or support, noted Hasanova.

But in a country where media often targets queer people this silence is not surprising according to Hasanova. Citing QueerRadar media monitoring reports from previous years, Hasanova said, local media bias in their coverage of LGBTQI+ appeared in over 70 percent of the stories the initiative monitored last year.

The media however is not the only place where silence looms when the LGBTQI+ community is targeted. In general, for many LGBTQI+ individuals who face discrimination and violence, there is little recourse through the police or any official judicial channels.

The most brazen example of the state's unwillingness to help the queer community was when in 2021 popular blogger Sevinc Huseynova made open calls to violence against the LGBTQI+ community on social media platforms. She was never reprimanded for her actions despite ample evidence of her encouraging people to commit violent crimes against queer people.

Fast forward to the present day, and inaction when addressing hate crimes, specifically those targeting LGBTQI+ in the country continues.

Azerbaijan does not have separate data or mechanisms in place, documenting hate crimes committed against the LGBTQI. The country also does not have legal protection against hate crimes and hate speech despite prior international calls to adopt anti-discrimination legislation.

According to ILGA Europe, an international non-governmental organization advocating for LGBTQ+ rights and freedoms, Azerbaijan has occupied the last place among 49 countries on the organization's Rainbow Index consecutively for years now.

In its most country report, ILGA Europe noted, that “hate crimes against the LGBTQI+ community continued to be a serious issue” in Azerbaijan during the reporting period. The report cited other instances of murder, physical assault, and arrests of community members.

Aytan, Nuray, Hulya, and others whose names and stories were never reported, or heard, are a living testament that in the absence of basic protection mechanisms, victims of abuse and harassment are left to their own devices with justice unlikely to be ever served.