Small European States Play Catch Up to Equality for LGBT

A rainbow flag is displayed from a window at Vogay, an association for the sexual and gender diversity, in Lausanne, Switzerland, in June 2020. When Switzerland became one of the last Western European nations to legalize same-sex marriage last year, it made waves next door in the tiny Alpine country of Liechtenstein. | REUTERS

• BY ENRIQUE ANARTE

• THOMSON REUTERS FOUNDATION

and Japan Times

When Switzerland became one of the last Western European nations to legalize same-sex marriage in 2021, it made waves next door in the tiny Alpine country of Liechtenstein.

Two days after the Swiss vote, lawmakers signaled near-unanimous support for same-sex marriage during a parliamentary session in the principality, one of several European microstates that trail their neighbors on LGBT equality laws.

This year, the nation of fewer than 40,000 people is also due to host its first Pride event.

“I guess it’s always been like this; we’ve always waited for bigger countries to take the initiative,” said Stefan Marxer, a board member at Liechtenstein’s only LGBT group, Flay.

Catholicism is the official religion in the principality, which advocacy group ILGA-Europe rates 40th of 49 observed European countries when it comes to legal protections for LGBT people, just behind Romania and Ukraine.

Only Malta scores highly among Europe’s microstates on LGBT rights legislation — clinching the top spot in the ILGA rating.

Under Liechtenstein’s current laws, same-sex couples can access civil unions granting them some economic and social benefits, but cannot adopt, and there is no specific legislation for transgender people to change their legal name and gender.

Liechtenstein’s monarch, Prince Hans-Adam II — who can veto any new legislation passed by parliament — has opposed extending marriage rights to LGBT couples if that meant they were granted the same rights to adopt children as heterosexual couples.

“If two homosexuals adopt some boys, that’s not unproblematic,” he said in a radio interview last February, adding that children have a right to grow up in a “normal family”.

Liechtenstein’s government declined to comment.

San Marino only lifted a ban on same-sex sexual relations in 2004 and there are no LGBT advocacy organizations in the northern Italian enclave. | REUTERS

Despite the prince’s remarks, Marxer said pressure for change was mounting.

“All the German-speaking countries except for Liechtenstein have opened marriage for same-sex couples. It’s time for Liechtenstein to do the same,” he said.

‘Winds of change’

Religion and tradition also hold heavy sway in the tiny states of Andorra, San Marino and Monaco, fellow laggards when it comes to LGBT rights protections, according to ILGA-Europe.

The governments of Andorra, Monaco and San Marino also declined to comment.

San Marino, which is rated 42nd by ILGA-Europe, only lifted a ban on same-sex sexual relations in 2004 and there are no LGBT advocacy organizations in the northern Italian enclave.

Instead, Paolo Rondelli, the republic’s only openly gay member of parliament, said he had joined the local chapter of Arcigay, Italy’s biggest LGBT group, in the neighboring city of Rimini.

But Rondelli said “winds of change” from bigger countries were starting to sway San Marino’s “conservative traditions.”

A referendum to enshrine a ban on homophobic discrimination in the constitution gathered 71.46% of the vote in 2019. Last year, San Marino voted to legalize abortion.

It could still take time for politicians to put LGBT equality — including same-sex marriage — on their legislative agenda, Rondelli added.

“Most MPs come from Catholic parties, so speaking about LGBT rights isn’t their first priority, even though most of them voted in favor of civil unions in 2018,” he said.

In Andorra, a microstate sandwiched between France and Spain in the Pyrenees, the Catholic Church has sought to put limits on pro-LGBT reform, campaigners said.

Andorra, which is headed by two co-princes — the French president and the Roman Catholic bishop of Urgell, in the Spanish region of Catalonia — passed a far-reaching gay civil unions law in 2014 but stopped short of using the term marriage.

“The only reason why it isn’t called gay marriage is because the bishopric (the bishop of Urgell) won’t accept it,” said Loan Poulet, a 33-year-old Andorran educator and writer who has written a book for children covering trans issues.

He said large numbers of immigrants to the country had helped change attitudes, and — due partly to the broad civil partnerships law — Andorra is ranked 26th by ILGA-Europe.

Still, LGBT rights advocates said the political establishment showed little urgency for deeper reform.

“Andorran institutions are reluctant to acknowledge that our bigger neighbors have an influence on us, because it’s a small country that wants to keep its own identity,” said Rocio Soler, president of Andorra’s only LGBT group, DiversAnd.

LGBT people in wealthy Monaco say they find it hard to be open about their sexuality in the city-state, which lacks anti-discrimination laws and bans same-sex marriage and adoption. | BLOOMBERG

Low rates of crime, including homophobic or transphobic attacks, in the principality of 77,000 people may also explain the dearth of legislation enshrining LGBT rights, she said.

“Because you don’t hear about violence against certain groups, people think that we’re fine, that we don’t need anything else,” said Soler, adding that the country’s size might partly explain the persistence of conservative attitudes.

“The fact that we all know each other increases the social pressure and makes it harder to come out,” she said.

Discretion

LGBT people in wealthy Monaco said they also found it hard to be open about their sexuality in the city-state, which lacks anti-discrimination laws and bans same-sex marriage and adoption. Gay civil unions were recently approved.

The principality of some 40,000 people is ranked 45th on LGBT equality by ILGA-Europe — the lowest of the microstates. The Vatican, the world’s smallest country, was not included in the survey.

More than 40 men living or working in Monaco, where Catholicism is also the official religion, contacted by the Thomson Reuters Foundation through a gay dating app said they felt uncomfortable about coming out.

Wim Prior, a Belgian man who has founded a Gay Lifestyle Association (GLAM) in Monaco with his partner, said a low-key gay scene was taking root.

“The word discretion is a very important word in Monaco,” he said, adding that attitudes were starting to change.

“Monaco is really open and safe,” he said.

In Liechtenstein, LGBT rights advocates hope Switzerland’s landmark vote will turn signs of progress into legal guarantees.

Elia Deplazes, a 32-year-old Swiss trans man who lives in Liechtenstein, was able to find legal security under his home country’s newly passed pro-LGBT laws, which include a trans self-ID regulation which took effect this month.

Deplazes, who married a man and had a child before coming out as trans, has been assured by Liechtenstein’s state-run human rights body that both his marriage and parenting rights will be respected due to the Swiss legislation. “It’s going be the first time in the history of this country that this happens,” he said.