New Research Masculine Bias is Present on Both Gay and Straights But How About UR Career?
 |
Masculine bias is present among gay and straight men, according to new research, and it’s having an effect on feminine men’s careers
Get Guardian Australia’s weekend culture and lifestyle email
14:00 UTC Monday, 30 January 2023
Gay and heterosexual men prefer masculine-presenting men in leadership positions over those deemed more feminine, according to a University of Sydney study, suggesting that gay men themselves are “complicit” in penalizing “feminine-presenting members of their own community”.
Ben Gerrard, the study’s lead author, told Guardian Australia: “In society there is a strong association between gayness and femininity and many gay men grow up with an unconscious idea that gayness is bad, so they may consciously or unconsciously suppress feminine traits.”
In the study – published in the journal Sex Roles – researchers asked 256 Australian men (half who are gay, and half who are heterosexual) to select a gay man to represent Sydney in a mock tourism campaign. They were shown videos of six gay, white male actors performing the same short script in two ways: with their body language and voice adjusted to appear more feminine and with their performance delivered in a more traditionally masculine style. Participants were asked to choose the candidate they thought people would most admire and think of as a leader.
Sign up for our rundown of must-reads, pop culture and tips for the weekend, every Saturday morning
The study found that participants, including gay men, were significantly more likely to cast a masculine-presenting actor than a feminine actor. The research suggests that despite being part of the same minority group, gay men may be “complicit” in bias against effeminate gay men from reaching higher-status positions.
It adds to growing research about gay men’s “intraminority” biases against feminine-presenting men, whereas masculine qualities, behaviors, and appearances are regarded as more favorable.
Gerrard, who recently played the lead role in American Psycho: The Musical at the Sydney Opera House, was inspired to investigate gay men’s prejudice towards feminine-presenting men after his experiences as an actor. He is concerned that media depictions of gay men are not truly representative of the wider gay community and are increasingly masculine in nature, with gay roles often given to straight men – such as Daniel Craig in Netflix’s Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery.
Dr. Jamie Hakim is a lecturer in culture and media at King’s College London and researches queer intimacy in digital spaces. He recognizes this masculine bias in gay communities, which can be found on apps such as Grindr and Instagram. “There is a persistence in the gay culture of eroticizing particular forms of masculinity … It can cause lots of anxiety and a sense of failure for those who don’t feel they match a certain image,” he says.
Beyond self-image, masculine bias may have wider implications for gay men in the workplace. The University of Sydney study references the “gay glass ceiling effect” for those who appear more feminine, which may mean they are passed over for more senior positions.
Lisa Annese, the CEO of Diversity Council Australia, says she is “not surprised” by the findings. But she adds: “It’s not just gay men who stand to lose by not acting in traditionally masculine ways. This narrow focus on a single, dominant form of masculinity as a favorable form of leadership is a wider issue.”
She says while gay men may be able to change their behaviors to act in more masculine ways, women are often penalized for acting in a more masculine way.
However, Annese says there is clear evidence to show that traditionally more feminine qualities of compassion, collaboration, and empathy are important in organizational leadership.
Rise of the sides: how Grindr finally recognized gay men who aren’t tops or bottoms
Research conducted in 2018 by the council found that only 32% of LGBTQ+ Australians were out to everyone they worked with. Those not out were more than twice as likely to report feeling downhearted and less productive at work.
Brodie Tripp, a transgender woman living in Melbourne, has a unique perspective on gender presentation in the workplace. “Prior to transitioning, I lived as a queer man and I saw gay men told to ‘tone it down’ or that they dressed ‘too gay to be taken seriously’ at work,” she says.
Now living as a trans woman, she recognizes the penalties placed on women who act assertively in the workplace and as a member of a minority with very little visible representation in the workplace, “everything I do is seen as representing my trans identity too”.
However, Annese says there may be a better answer than traditional leadership training courses and often perpetuate the idea that masculine forms of leadership are beneficial.
“Many courses focus on encouraging ‘shapeshifting’ into other forms of behavior. What we need is to create workplaces where we have a range of diverse leadership representations and everyone can be their authentic selves,” she says.
Gerrard agrees: “Only when we demand a diverse range of representations can we truly have acceptance for our community.”
Lend us a hand in 2023
We have a small favor to ask. Tens of millions have placed their trust in the Guardian’s fearless journalism since we started publishing 200 years ago, turning to us in moments of crisis, uncertainty, solidarity, and hope. More than 1.5 million supporters, from 180 countries, now power us financially – keeping us open to all, and fiercely independent.
Unlike many others, the Guardian has no shareholders and no billionaire owner. Just the determination and passion for delivering high-impact global reporting, always free from commercial or political influence. Reporting like this is vital for democracy, for fairness and to demand better from the powerful.
And we provide all this for free, for everyone to read. We do this because we believe in information equality. Greater numbers of people can keep track of the events shaping our world, understand their impact on people and communities, and become inspired to take meaningful action. Millions can benefit from open access to quality, truthful news, regardless of their ability to pay for it.
What are they called:
What is it called when a man is feminine?
Androgyny is a synonym. Often, it has been used to refer to males with feminine qualities. Genderfuck: This can be both a gender identity and gender expression term. Trans* Identities and Lives Glossary | Gender and Sexuality Centerhttps://web.uri.edu › resources › lgbtqa-glossary › trans-1...
Search for: What is it called when a man is feminine?
Do girls like feminine guys?
"Women prefer great degrees of masculinity for short-term partners, but for long-term relationships what we are finding is that they prefer more feminine and definitely more healthy men," said David Perrett at the University of St Andrews, who led the research
Comments